Members' picks

Ten cigars.
Nine opinions.

No committee vote and no universal ranking—just each member's ten cigars worth reaching for again.

Member list · 01

Cory's Top Ten

The current rotation. Rankings are personal, subject to new releases, old boxes, and a persuasive evening at the table.

  1. 01Arturo Fuente OPUSX 25
  2. 02God of Fire Serie B
  3. 03E.P. Carrillo Endure
  4. 04Casa Carrillo Ascend
  5. 05The Tabernacle David
  6. 06E.P. Carrillo Pledge
  7. 07Aging Room Quattro Nicaragua
  8. 08Arturo Fuente Don Carlos
  9. 09Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story
  10. 10Padrón 2000
Filed in Big Bear CityUpdated November 2026

Beyond the ranking

The score matters less than the second cigar.

For the complete tasting ritual—cigar, spirit, and pairing—open the Fellowship's Reviews.

Open the reviews